baking steel pizza steel oven steel mild carbon steel A36 44W bbq steel homemade pizza stone
baking steel pizza steel oven steel mild carbon steel A36 44W bbq steel homemade pizza stone
baking steel pizza steel oven steel mild carbon steel A36 44W bbq steel homemade pizza stone
baking steel pizza steel oven steel mild carbon steel A36 44W bbq steel homemade pizza stone
baking steel pizza steel oven steel mild carbon steel A36 44W bbq steel homemade pizza stone
baking steel pizza steel oven steel mild carbon steel A36 44W bbq steel homemade pizza stone
baking steel pizza steel oven steel mild carbon steel A36 44W bbq steel homemade pizza stone
baking steel pizza steel oven steel mild carbon steel A36 44W bbq steel homemade pizza stone
baking steel pizza steel oven steel mild carbon steel A36 44W bbq steel homemade pizza stone
baking steel pizza steel oven steel mild carbon steel A36 44W bbq steel homemade pizza stone
baking steel pizza steel oven steel mild carbon steel A36 44W bbq steel homemade pizza stone
Average Joe (14x16", 1/4") with finger holes
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, baking steel pizza steel oven steel mild carbon steel A36 44W bbq steel homemade pizza stone
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, baking steel pizza steel oven steel mild carbon steel A36 44W bbq steel homemade pizza stone
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, baking steel pizza steel oven steel mild carbon steel A36 44W bbq steel homemade pizza stone
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, baking steel pizza steel oven steel mild carbon steel A36 44W bbq steel homemade pizza stone
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, baking steel pizza steel oven steel mild carbon steel A36 44W bbq steel homemade pizza stone
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, baking steel pizza steel oven steel mild carbon steel A36 44W bbq steel homemade pizza stone
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, baking steel pizza steel oven steel mild carbon steel A36 44W bbq steel homemade pizza stone
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, baking steel pizza steel oven steel mild carbon steel A36 44W bbq steel homemade pizza stone
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, baking steel pizza steel oven steel mild carbon steel A36 44W bbq steel homemade pizza stone
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, baking steel pizza steel oven steel mild carbon steel A36 44W bbq steel homemade pizza stone
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, baking steel pizza steel oven steel mild carbon steel A36 44W bbq steel homemade pizza stone
  • Load image into Gallery viewer, Average Joe (14x16", 1/4") with finger holes

Average Joe (14x16", 1/4") with finger holes

Regular price
$128.99
Sale price
$128.99
Regular price
Sold out
Unit price
per 
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Meet The Average Joe with Finger Holes — the same hardworking pizza steel you know and love, now with added convenience for easier lifting and handling. Designed for home cooks, pizza lovers, and BBQ enthusiasts alike, this pizza oven steel delivers exceptional heat retention and even cooking for crispy, restaurant-quality pizza at home.

Made from solid North American mild carbon steel, The Average Joe outperforms traditional pizza stones by transferring heat more efficiently, helping create crispier crusts, faster cook times, and beautifully browned pizzas.

The integrated finger holes make moving and repositioning the steel easier, especially when cooking at high temperatures in ovens or on BBQs.

Whether you’re baking pizza in your kitchen oven, firing up the BBQ, or experimenting with artisan bread, this steel is built to become a staple in your cooking setup.

Features

  • 14" deep x 16" wide x 1/4" thick
    (35.5cm x 40.6cm x 0.64cm)
  • Approx. 15 lbs
  • Precision laser cut with rounded edges
  • Finger holes for easier lifting and handling
  • Dual-sided cooking surface
  • Works in ovens, on BBQs, and stovetops
  • Excellent for pizza, bread, smash burgers, vegetables, and high-heat cooking
  • Canadian made

Why Use a Pizza Steel?

Unlike traditional pizza stones, a pizza oven steel absorbs and transfers heat rapidly and evenly, helping you achieve:

  • Crispier pizza crusts
  • Better browning and caramelization
  • Faster recovery between pizzas
  • Improved bread baking performance
  • Greater durability with no cracking

The 1/4" thickness makes The Average Joe a versatile option that heats quickly while still delivering outstanding cooking performance.

Care Instructions

Your steel arrives with a sandblasted finish and is ready to season.

  • Apply a thin coat of high smoke-point oil before first use
  • Heat gradually to build seasoning over time
  • Clean with warm water and dry thoroughly
  • Avoid soaking or prolonged moisture exposure
  • Lightly oil after use to help prevent rust
  • Surface will naturally darken and develop a seasoned patina similar to cast iron

Simple, reliable, and built to last — The Average Joe with Finger Holes is a dependable pizza steel designed to elevate homemade pizza night.

**RESTOCKING BEGINNING OF JUNE**

Customer Reviews
5.0 Based on 11 Reviews
5 ★
100% 
11
4 ★
0% 
0
3 ★
0% 
0
2 ★
0% 
0
1 ★
0% 
0
Write a Review

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
EP
03/14/2024
Edward P.
Canada Canada
I recommend this product

Game changer for homemade pizza!

This was a present from my wife and it has absolutely upped the quality of my homemade pizza! Everyone who has tried my pizza baked on the Atlas steel swears they are having a slice of authentic New York City pizza. Baked in the middle of my oven at 550’F with convection and it’s perfect every time.

JB
12/21/2023
James B.
Canada Canada
I recommend this product

Good Quality

There is a learning curve from stone to steel. Great for baking bread as well as pizza

GC
07/04/2023
Gemma C.
Canada Canada
I recommend this product

Best pizza party yet

Great. Works well on my little bbq and makes the best pizza yet.

GS
05/08/2023
Gord S.
Canada Canada
I recommend this product

Great Pizza

Picked up a pizza from Roadside Store - turned out excellent on the Atlas Steel!!

B
12/28/2022
Bill
I recommend this product

Yes you should buy one!

Restaurant quality pizza in a home oven! Highly recommend the product and and the customer service from Atlas Steel Co.